Bus plans
ESCC has been obliged to write a Bus Service Improvement Plan. To that end our Local Transport Authority says it will build an ‘enhanced partnership’ with the County’s bus companies – meaning they’ll staff up and take an interest. Anna Sabin takes a look at the proposals.
The bus companies that serve East Sussex are all talking the talk – but the walking/driving is mixed.
It’s good that they say, if they get funded, they’ll aim for:
- A fully integrated service with simple, multi-modal tickets – (bus, train, bike hire?)
- High-quality information for all passengers in more places – 80% of bus stops to have Real Time Passenger Information (RTPI) – except a proportion of them will be as QR codes needing a smart phone and an app.
- Better bus stops
- Better buses running on cleaner fuel – aiming at 2050 to get to zero (exhaust pipe) carbon
- Better turn-up-and-go frequencies that keep running into the evenings and at weekends – see below for the level of ambition for Hastings
- Tap on tap off payment
- Reduced fares for under 30’s, simplified fares, group and family tickets and short hop fares
- Mobility hubs in towns
- More bus priority measures – including the ‘Wave Corridor’ Hastings-Bexhill-Eastbourne
- More buses in urban areas and along main corridors
- Reintroduction of selected bus routes into pedestrian priority areas, maybe in Hastings, they haven’t specified
- A parking enforcement officer in some towns (in Hastings?)
- Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR), and maybe a Park and Ride in Peacehaven (why not for Hastings too?)
There are red herrings… like thinking a lead should be taken by ‘the aspirations of our bus operators and the priorities of our stakeholders, especially bus users’ – because that’s how you get more of the same which hasn’t been popular for years.
They rather hopefully say these things will happen:
- Journey time reductions – based on key corridors and prioritised congestion spot bus priority schemes
- Reliability – reducing mileage lost through congestion, vehicle breakdowns and staff shortage
- Punctuality – measuring the percentage of bus journeys that run on time – promising 95%
- Number of passengers carried each year – planned to increase
- Bus network to meet all needs (?!)
- Technical and operational improvement
- Future growth
- Digital Demand Response Transport (is that a bus-shaped taxi you have to book 12-24 hours in advance?)
- Evening and weekend services
But they will need Low Traffic Neighbourhoods – or bus/bicycle only roads with the cars filtered out (bus gates), or road charging or withdrawal of parking or something to achieve them.
If good sense and a love of fresh air breaks out, these reallocations of road space could come to pass. The best chance of it would be to have a green-street, shared-transport aspiration written into the East Sussex Local Transport Plan. Fortuitously, this is about to be updated. As the Bus Service Improvement Plan is obliged to align with the Local Transport Plan, there is, right now, the mechanism for a really big change.
The question is, now ESCC says they’ll ‘seek to redress the balance in modal share between private and public transport’, what level of conviction and imagination will they give to it?
BSIP aspirations specific to Hastings:
Wave routes
99 & 98 – will run six buses an hour between them during the day, Monday to Saturday plus hourly buses into the evening (but until how late?).
Currently the 98 runs 2 buses, unevenly, an hour and the 99 runs 3 buses an hour – both stop around 6.30pm but the 99 runs 2 or 3 more buses till 9pm
The thing is – the two services are not the same – if you just want to get to Eastbourne from Hastings Station and back, the 98 takes you all round the houses and wastes your time. They can only be counted as one service running every ten minutes at the start and finish of the route – not for any start or finish point in between. What’s more they are suggesting further splitting the 98 route in two making the ‘every ten minutes’ promise serve even fewer bus stops. This means the hourly evening service will be two hourly for any one not at the extreme ends of the routes, where 99 & 98 run on the same roads.
Conclusion for the coastal ‘Wave’ connection: not much gain
Satellite towns and villages
The following Hastings bus services will run an hourly service during the day and into the evening (they don’t say till when) and a 2 hourly service on Sunday:
Route 2 – Hastings Station to Tenterden via Conquest Hosp. – currently 7 buses 10am to 6pm – a bit less than one bus an hour
– loses its regular Hospital stop which will have to be booked in advance through the DDRT
– gains an hourly evening service to Tenterden, 2 hourly on Sunday and the DDRT arrangement for the hospital 7 days a week incl. evenings….
100 & 101 – Rye to Conquest Hosp. via Hastings Station – currently between them they’re half hourly in the morning and hourly in the afternoon till 6pm
– gains an hourly evening service and 2 hourly Sunday service
254, 304 & 305 – are the same bus service (the 254 runs earlier, the 305 runs later) but between them they run Silverhill-Hastings-Hawkhurst hourly
– gains an hourly evening service and 2 hourly Sunday service
349 – Hastings – Bodiam – Hawkhurst – currently a 2 hourly service Monday to Saturday (just one bus goes via Conquest at 6.30am) and a 2 hourly service from 8am to 4pm on Sunday
– gains twice as many buses each day plus evenings and maybe a longer Sunday service
Conclusion for Hastings’ satellite towns and villages: people will get much less than a turn up and go service but will be less marooned in the evenings and on Sundays
Town Centre buses and the school bus from Pett
7, 24 & 27 – Hastings Station – Bohemia or Braybrook or St. Helen’s Park Road are currently ‘shoppers buses’ each running 5 or 6 times in middle of the day, Mon to Sat
347 – Hastings-Ore-Pett is a school bus plus 3 services running between start and end of the school day –
All 7,24,27 and 347 are to be replaced with Digital Demand Response Transport….
Conclusion for the people of the central southern residential parts of town and Pett: the DDRT system will suit the predictable school transport which will probably carry on as before. Everyone else will have to work out how to make DDRT work for them. I hope they demand a lot and make it work!
Hastings’ six town bus routes
20 – Ore – Hastings Station – London Road – Old Church Road – Hollington Tesco currently runs every 15 minutes 6.30am to 7.50pm and then hourly till 11pm. (Castleham Industrial Estate mornings only, Ore Down Farm less well served early and late.) Sunday service half-hourly 7.30am to 5.30pm
– gains an hourly evening service to Harley Shute and a half-hourly evening service Ore – Hastings Station – Hollington
21 & 21A – Ore – Hastings Station currently runs every 15 minutes alternately using Malvern Way or Mount Pleasant meaning that, for people using it from mid-route, it’s only a half-hourly service
– gains evening frequency (unspecified) and Sunday services plus ‘route simplification’ (?), route extensions of two buses per hour to Harley Shute via Pevensey Road, West Hill and Filsham Road, on the current 23 route. (The 23 currently runs hourly so here the frequency will be doubled)
22 & 22C – Ore – Hastings Station – London Road – Hollington which alternates routes at the beginning and end, starting along Clifton Road or Mount Pleasant or Malvern Way and finishing at big Tesco or Harley Shute. Passengers needing a specific beginning or end to the route have a half or third of the overall half-hourly frequency from 6.15am to 6.15pm then hourly till 9pm and a Sunday hourly service from 9am to 6pm
– gains ‘improvement’ to evening service tbc and day time frequency from hourly or three-quarter hourly to half-hourly for both the Harley Shute and the Tesco destinations
23 – Hastings Station to Hollington Tesco via the Hospital in the mornings, then direct, not visiting the Hospital, in the afternoons – currently hourly during the day
– gains extra hourly service evenings and Sundays and a half hourly service (twice the old frequency) during the day and a re-route improving coverage away from London, Pevensey, West Hill Roads (taken over by the 21) and transferring its service to Harley Shute (via the Seafront, I guess).
– loses – service to Hospital
26 & 26A – Hastings Station – Conquest Hospital, clockwise via London Road and anti-clockwise via St. Helens Road currently half hourly along the 2 routes but with 4 unevenly spaced services from end to end, as long as you don’t mind what route you take, from 7am to 7pm
– gains an additional hourly evening and Sunday service for people at the beginning or end of the routes, ie. the Station or the Hospital, but a two hourly service for anyone wanting to catch the bus from anywhere else along the route.
28 – Hastings – West Hill – Conquest Hospital currently the least loved bus service in Hastings because it runs every 70 minutes!
– gains a half hourly service during the day Monday to Saturday, an hourly evening service and a 2 hourly Sunday service
– loses Hastings Station and only runs from Priory Meadow (not so bad)
Conclusion for the 6 Hastings town bus services:
– Frequency – would improve from hourly to half hourly but not beyond – you won’t get your bus coming every 15 minutes unless it does already. This falls way short of their turn-up-and-go aspiration. (Frequencies could be doubled with smaller vehicles eg. licensed cars.)
– Service hours – it is proposed that all 6 routes extend their hours into the evening with at least an hourly service (we don’t yet know to how late) and to at least a two hourly Sunday service
– Coverage – would be extended westward with Harley Shute being served by three different buses, by one hourly and by the other two half-hourly. There would then be 6 north-south routes running roughly half hourly (or better if it’s the 20 or 21 from Ore). There would, however, still be no bus running east-west along the whole length of the Seafront, the Ridge or any route between the two.
If Hastings wants fewer cars on its roads, safe and pleasant routes for walking and cycling at the same time as being able to get about efficiently and cheaply, it wants to get that desire into its Local Plan and into the the County’s Local Transport Plan. Left as it is, this unimpressive aspiration for half hourly bus services in this Bus Service Improvement Plan won’t be nearly improvement enough to achieve it.
If you’re enjoying HOT and would like us to continue providing fair and balanced reporting on local matters please consider making a donation. Click here to open our PayPal donation link. Thank you for your continued support!
3 Comments
Please read our comment guidelines before posting on HOT
Leave a comment
(no more than 350 words)
Also in: Transport
« Bus future still unclear though some Stagecoach cuts reversedDo cars dominate your street? »
An extremely interesting article.
As an ex driver working for 4 different companies over 31 years including Stagecoach ( Silverhill) I can confirm that Stagecoach is not fit for purpose.
Secondly we must Stop calling it ” A bus service”
Make no mistake it is a business out to make a profit for its shareholders.
Hastings is unique with the geography of the greater Hastings district causing its own issues – an example is long wheelbase buses ” grounding” at Harley Shute traffic lights when turning left. It is stated on Stagecoach own website that there is a shortage of qualified driver, from my own experience,if they paid a wage that a married man with two kids could live on rather than just exist, then perhaps they would encourage new drivers to choose a career in public transport. Stagecoach pay is absolutely appalling with a very high turn over of staff . Next comes conditions of employment.
Imagine starting work at 05:00 in the morning then driving for 5 hours without a break and don’t get me started as to where bus drivers are able to go to the toilet.
Many years ago Brighton and Hove bus company introduced the ” busy Bee service 7″ A seven minute minibus from Hove to Brighton centre – the hospital and finally the Marina. It was an instant hit and to this day the route Seven from Blatchington Road Hove to Brighton Marina is one of their most profitable routes together with the Route 12/12A/12X ( Brighton to Eastbourne) every 10 mins.
To conclude.
Stagecoach must pay drivers a decent wage to attract new drivers, increase the frequency which in turn will encourage passengers to have confidence to actually choose to use the buses.
Many routes are indeed unprofitable and will continue to require County Council subsidies.
Ultimately because Stagecoach is a PLC it is all about profit.
And don’t get me started on asset stripping. Selling off Eastbourne Garage – Rye Garage and others
Profit comes before Service – buses are run as a business for profit and is definitely NOT A SERVICE.
Comment by David Barker — Wednesday, Sep 7, 2022 @ 15:23
Much of the “chattering” class has much to learn regarding Hastings in the bleak mid winter,good bus timeings are fine but i would like to see you “great Good” woke folk, get from Ore to Bexhill work a 10hr shift in the depths of winter
Comment by robert — Sunday, Jul 24, 2022 @ 23:10
I am in full agreement with the thrust of Anna’s article. Life in the town would be much improved on many levels by a general upgrade of the bus services.
I am a regular user of Hastings town and 99 bus routes. I would like to see a substantial implementation of the ‘talk’, especially improved bus stops (with shelters and seating) as well as an App that reflects real bus movements, not simply reproducing the timetable.
Comment by LINDSAY TALMUD — Friday, Feb 4, 2022 @ 18:21