Less than five months after being formed, HBC’s Red/Green Cabinet has been dismantled, as Green members Cllrs Julia Hilton (third from left) and Glenn Haffenden (second from right) lose their Cabinet seats. The axe was wielded, on orders from on high, by council leader Paul Barnett. Other Labour Cabinet members pictured are, from left, Cllrs Andy Batsford, Judy Rogers, Simon Willis and Maya Evans. The other Labour member, Cllr Ali Roark, was not present for the photo (photo: HBC).
Going, going, gone: HBC’s red/green alliance ended on national Labour orders
Under orders from national Labour, council leader Paul Barnett has reluctantly ended Hastings Borough Council’s red/green co-operative alliance after less than six months and relieved the two Green portfolio holders of their positions and Cabinet posts. HOT’s Chris Connelley reports.
After weeks of rumour and speculation, it is now official. The Labour/ Green co-operative alliance on Hastings Borough Council is over, after less than six months.
The announcement was made early on Friday 14 October with the release of a statement from the borough’s five Green councillors. Headed ‘National Labour Party Destroys Local Alliance With Greens’, it asserts that “the national Labour Party has threatened local Labour leader, Cllr Paul Barnett, with expulsion from the party if he doesn’t remove the two Green portfolio holders from cabinet”.
The alliance came into being after May’s council elections, which saw Labour lose its overall majority for the first time in many years, following the loss of three seats to an ascendant Green Party. This followed another difficult set of results for Labour in 2021, when it lost five seats, four to the Conservatives, in Baird, Ore, Silverhill and St Helens, and one to the Greens, in Old Hastings ward.
With Labour on 15 seats, the Conservatives 12 and the Greens five, no single party was able to assume overall control, and this year’s Annual Council meeting was delayed as negotiations continued between the three parties on various permutations of possible alliance to create a majority scenario.
Co-operative alliance
After intense discussion, and considerable toing and froing, the lockjam was broken when Labour and the Greens agreed to work together as a co-operative alliance, with the smaller party securing two of the eight seats on Cabinet, the top table committee at which key strategic and budgetary decisions are made.
Under this arrangement, Cllr Julia Hilton, leader of the Greens, took on the climate change, natural environment and active travel portfolio, with newcomer Cllr Glenn Haffenden assuming responsibility for the urban environment. They joined six Labour councillors, under council leader Barnett and new deputy leader Maya Evans.
The Green statement suggests that the arrangement was working well and that “openness and transparency were growing,” before laying the blame for the alliance collapse firmly at the door of national Labour, noting that, “Cllr Barnett has now bowed to this pressure, which changes the terms under which we have been so successfully working. He is being forced to run what will be an unstable and inefficient minority administration”.
The statement continues: “That national Labour Party officials should wade in and pull the strings of the local Labour group with no thought for the best interests of the people of Hastings and St Leonards shows a complete disregard for local democracy. Clearly the national Labour Party cares more about its own internal rules than the lives of people in our town and places little value in parties working together”.
The Greens go on to invite local Labour councillors and activists to “protest against this sort of high-handed behaviour on the part of their leadership, and to defy national Labour diktats that go against the interests of local communities,” before listing the achievements of their two Cabinet members, most notably bringing back the grounds maintenance contract in-house as a direct council service.
The Labour Party issued its response later on Friday, claiming that “following the local elections in Hastings, as the largest political group on the council, the Labour Party, led by Cllr Paul Barnett looked to form a cabinet and lead the council. With this in mind Cllr Paul Barnett reached out to other local political parties to discuss a way forward for the good of the town.
“These local discussions resulted in the agreement where the Local Green party would be invited to take up two Cabinet roles and work on a policy by policy basis together for the good of the town”.
New arrangement
“Since then, despite many weeks of negotiations and discussions it has become clear that the current cabinet arrangement will need to conclude. The Labour Group will look to set up a new arrangement where they can ensure the best possible outcomes for Hastings in agreement with Labour’s national executive committee.”
The statement concluded with a quote from Cllr Barnett thanking the Green Cabinet members and promising that “I will be looking to find a way to continue that constructive dialogue as we move forward. We are all passionate about our town, the climate change challenge and the huge need to protect our residents from the Conservatives destructive policies.”
The Labour press release provides no explanation as to why the arrangement could not continue.
HOT understands that, in an attempt to retain overall control, Cllr Barnett had tried to tempt the Greens with a new arrangement, under which they would continue to support the Labour administration on major votes in return for the offer of leading roles on new commissions dealing with climate change and culture short of Cabinet status. This proposal was rejected by the smaller party.
Minority administration
Cllr Barnett now confronts the difficult prospect of leading the Council as a minority administration at a time of deep economic uncertainty. His first task will be to fill the vacated Cabinet posts, with deputy mayor Margi O’Callaghan and newcomer John Cannan identified as possible contenders. The new appointments are likely to be accompanied by a reshuffle of portfolios, with veteran Judy Rodgers and Ali O’Rourke tipped for promotion.
Green councillors are due to meet with party members later this month and no further announcements are expected until after this.
Initial reaction on social media was relatively restrained, possibly overshadowed by major events in national government following the sacking of Chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng by Prime Minister Liz Truss after just 38 days.
If you’re enjoying HOT and would like us to continue providing fair and balanced reporting on local matters please consider making a donation. Click here to open our PayPal donation link. Thank you for your continued support!
8 Comments
Please read our comment guidelines before posting on HOT
Leave a comment
(no more than 350 words)
Also in: Politics
« Hart to fight deselection by local Tory executiveLabour pains over candidate selection »
Having also watched the recent shocking Al Jazeera documentary, The Labour Files, this comes as no surprise. Kier Starmers party want complete control. I wont be voting Labour anymore.
Comment by Jaen Loftin — Monday, Oct 17, 2022 @ 14:46
The article appears to lay the blame wholly on Labour central office and yet it is clear to all that certain Labour forces locally have precipitated this crisis for that is what it is. The voting public of Hastings now deserve a full explanation of how any significant decisions, primarily finance and planning, can now be made by a minority Labour council. Surely now all parties, Labour, Conservative, and Green must collaborate on agreeing a working executive which can stop the council coming to a standstill. Labour acting on their own now has no validity at all.
Comment by ken davis — Monday, Oct 17, 2022 @ 09:00
Labour thinks if it refuses to align or work with anyone else, that will force voters back to voting for Labour. Well they wont. Did not work with them refusing to work with SNP. Lost their integrity a long time ago, and continue to do so. If you have been purged and maligned and falsely defamed you are in a better class of people.
Labour does not understand, they cannot win. unless they align with others, They will never have an overall majority in Parliament without working with other parties. I don’t know who they are going for in trying to persuade who to vote for them. Just about alienated everyone.
Everyone knows about the tricks, and word of mouth and knowing the decent people they have purged and maligned is enough. I don’t think there is any future for this country except Tory for the next decades.
Comment by J B KNIGHT — Sunday, Oct 16, 2022 @ 23:54
How disapointing, but having recently seen the three-part Al Jazeera investigation into the way Laboour Party HQ staff worked to undermine branches and others in the Labour Party, I am not surprised. Just as worrying is the way no major media in the UK have reported this scandal.
In case anyone thinks my sympathies have led to this comment, I was a member of the Labour Party until I resigned in protest at the failure of Jeremy Corbyn to speak out against Brexit.
Comment by Paul Burns — Sunday, Oct 16, 2022 @ 23:14
I am so disappointed that national Labour has behaved in this way.
Paul Barnett was building a great cabinet with the two Green councillors and I felt that at long last I could support local Labour. I’ve disliked them since Chowney was leader and beyond. I felt there was hope once again with Paul Barnett leading.
Kier Starmer is going to have to tread very carefully and this sort of action won’t win him votes.
Comment by Liz Bourn — Sunday, Oct 16, 2022 @ 21:19
Good article except for the bit about being offered ‘leadership roles’ on new commissions for climate change and culture. Nothing so specific was offered. Councillor Barnett stated he was keen to support the extension of council policy making processes to include far greater involvement of partner organisations locally and regionally, and of local residents including, subject to resources, creation of a Health Equalities board, Hastings Cultural Trust and Hastings Environment Commission. No positions on any of these proposed bodies have been offered to Greens at this time. While interesting ideas and worth pursuing, all would take considerable time to put in place and use resources which the council simply doesn’t have. Hastings Green Party remains open to future conversations but are clear that the decision by national Labour means the existing cooperation agreement is null and void.
Comment by Julia Hilton — Sunday, Oct 16, 2022 @ 21:00
A good piece , shows both sides of the argument and wa fair I thought. Labour behaviour questionable whilst questions remain to why the greens did not accept a new deal on policy issues they care about. Both sides could work better with one another and hopefully over time for the good of the town they will.
Comment by James Prentice — Sunday, Oct 16, 2022 @ 19:24
Just to say that, unless you leave a genuine email address, we won’t be publishing any comments. The last point in the Comment guidelines above makes this clear.
Comment by Nick Weekes — Sunday, Oct 16, 2022 @ 16:51